18 September 2023

 

On 15 September 2023, at the request of the Government of Iraq, the UN Security Council took a step backwards in the pursuit for justice for ISIS by adopting resolution 2697 (2023). The resolution ends the mandate of United Nations Investigative Team to Promote Accountability for Crimes Committed by Da'esh/ISIL’s (UNITAD) in one year, on 17 September 2024. It also requests a report from the UN Secretary-General in January and a road-map for termination from UNITAD in March 2024.

 

This abrupt decision was taken without consultation with any ISIS survivors, despite the statement made on 12 September by a group of 48 international and Iraqi human rights groups that warned of the dangers of such a move and a similar statement by Nobel Laureate Nadia Murad and her counsel Amal Clooney on the same day.

 

UNITAD was created by the Security Council to ensure that evidence of ISIS’ crimes could be gathered on the ground in Iraq. It was clear at the time that this evidence-gathering was intended to be a first step, to be followed by prosecutions. At the Council session at which resolution 2379, creating UNITAD, was adopted, the representative of Sweden “welcomed the adoption of today's resolution, which is an important first step towards holding those responsible for the atrocities carried out by Daesh to account”. The ambassador of the US noted that “today's resolution is a … major first step towards addressing the ... crimes that include genocide”. France agreed that “this contribution by the Security Council to justice….must serve as a first step”. And the UK, which held the pen on the draft, promised that although “bringing Daesh to justice will take time…patience and resolve”, justice should be delivered because “we owe it to those who have suffered to press ahead, however long the road might be”.

 

Yet in a session that took less than 20 minutes on Friday, the Security Council ended UNITAD’s mandate. Instead of clarifying how the evidence collected by UNITAD will now be used to prosecute ISIS for genocide and crimes against humanity, the Security Council has limited the prospects of justice. Comments by states after the vote highlighted that UNITAD has given survivors the ‘opportunity’ to provide their testimony – but what is the point in them doing so, sometimes at great risk, if it is not to be used to convict those responsible for abusing them?

 

UN Security Council resolution 2170 (2014), passed under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, calls on states to “bring to justice, in accordance with applicable international law, foreign terrorist fighters of, ISIL”. But the Council itself has now made it more difficult for them to do so. To date Germany’s courts have been the only ones to bring ISIS to justice for international crimes – including the only three trials anywhere in the world in which an ISIS fighter has been convicted of genocide. So far Iraq has not recognized the jurisdiction of the ICC nor reformed its laws to criminalize genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes. Trials of ISIS figures in Iraq have been considered by the UN to violate international standards. And because Iraq applies the death penalty in such trials, UNITAD is prevented from sharing its evidence with Iraq under applicable UN rules. Survivors have also frequently shared their distrust in a purely national process.

 

The UN Secretary-General was requested “to submit to the Security Council, no later than 15 January 2024, a report setting out recommendations for implementing this request with full respect for the sovereignty of Iraq”. In our view, it is imperative that the UN make clear that:

 

- Survivors will be consulted, and their views taken into account in developing the report;

 

- Any evidence-sharing with Iraq will be in line with UNITAD’s Terms of Reference and applicable UN rules;

 

- Notwithstanding Iraq’s involvement in determining ‘modalities’ for evidence-sharing under the new resolution, cooperation with third states should continue in UNITAD’s final year in conformity with the terms of resolution 2379 and the Terms of Reference;

 

- Any evidence-sharing with any entity must fully respect the terms of the consent (or otherwise) provided by each victim or witness; and

 

- The UNSC should convene an urgent session in early 2024 to discuss the use of the evidence gathered by UNITAD including before an international court that can prosecute ISIL members for international crimes, as proposed by survivors and their counsel including in previous addresses to the Security Council.

 

It is regrettable that the Security Council has taken this step away from justice. The process can be salvaged – but only if states make this a priority.

 


Natia Navrouzov                                                    Amal Clooney                                           

Yazda                                                                  Counsel to Yazda                     

                                                                                                                 

Download the Statement here.

For the Arabic version, click here.                                                                                                                              

                                                                                                                                 

This statement is open to endorsements.
Natia Navrouzov, Legal Advocacy Director
Please email:
natia.navrouzov@yazda.org

14 Oct, 2024
The Hasna A. Trial – The beginning of a landmark case in the Netherlands for crimes committed by a Dutch national against Yazidi women
by Farhad Ali 15 Aug, 2024
Yazda statement for the 10th commemoration of the attacks on Kocho village in Sinjar
by Farhad Ali 14 Aug, 2024
Yazda Honors Victims of the 2007 Terrorist Attacks on Tel Azer and Siba Sheikh-Khedir in Sinjar
Show more
by Farhad Ali 14 Mar, 2024
The release of this crucial report follows the UN Security Council (UNSC) resolution to extend the mandate of the Investigative Team to Promote Accountability for Crimes Committed by Da’esh/ISIL ( UNITAD ) only until September 2024 ( UNSC resolution 2697/2023 ). The report reflects the concerns and recommendations of Iraqi NGOs and survivors' networks. Yazda, a member of the Coalition for Just Reparations ( C4JR ), joined an alliance of Iraqi NGOs in calling for comprehensive reparations for survivors of atrocity crimes perpetrated during the ISIL conflict in Iraq. In September 2023, prior to the passing of resolution 2697 by the UNSC, Yazda led the publication of a statement endorsed by 50 organizations expressing concerns about the imminent closure of UNITAD. Subsequently, within C4JR, Yazda facilitated consultations with NGOs online and in person, ensuring that their feedback was communicated to the UN, particularly in preparation for the UN Secretary-General's report released in January 2024 on Iraq’s request to receive UNITAD’s evidence. In parallel, Yazda consulted survivors’ networks, including Hope Givers, Survivors Voice Network (SVN), Speicher-1700 NGO, and the Yazidi Survivors Networks (YSN), incorporating their perspectives into the report. Natia Navrouzov, Executive Director at Yazda and co-author of the report, comments: “The report, especially its concrete recommendations, is a testament to the deep knowledge of Iraqi civil society on issues of justice and the lack thereof in Iraq. Iraqi organizations are the experts and should not be ignored. We advocated for the creation of UNITAD but were not involved in its termination. To this day, we have not been presented with a clear strategy from Iraq and the international community regarding the fate and more importantly, the use, of the evidence collected by UNITAD and what comes next. While UNITAD’s completion roadmap, due on 15 March 2024, may provide some answers, we were not meaningfully consulted on it either. Moving forward, we want to be part of the conversation and of the solution.” For the Arabic version of the Press Release, click here . For any inquiries, please contact info@yazda.org ### 300 North 27th Street, Suite C. - Lincoln, Nebraska 68503, USA info@yazda.org - www.yazda.org
by Farhad Ali 22 Jan, 2024
22 January 2024 Ceremonies in Baghdad, Solagh and the three villages (Hardan, Kocho and Qney) On 22 January 2024, under the auspice of the Office of the Prime Minister and in the presence of Iraqi and international officials and Yazidi community members, a funeral will be held in Baghdad following the identification of 41 Yazidi victims from Hardan, Kocho and Qney. Following this national-wide ceremony, the remains of the victims will be taken to Sinjar where a local-led ceremony will be organized on 24 January 2024, at the recently inaugurated Yazidi Genocide Memorial in Solagh. During this ceremony, Yazidi religious rituals will be performed. The remains of the victims will be then handed over to their families to allow them to bury them in their respective villages of Hardan, Kocho and Qney. From 24 to 26 January 2024, mourning days will be observed in these three villages and members of the community will be able to visit and pay their respects. The return of the sixth batch of remains and ongoing exhumations The identification of the remains was carried out by the Iraqi Medico-Legal Department (MLD) of Iraqi Ministry of Health, with the assistance of the UN Investigative Team for Accountability of Da’esh/ISIL (UNITAD) and the International Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP). The UN-supported exhumation process in Sinjar started in March 2019 and is ongoing. So far, around 60 mass graves have been exhumed and around 20 still need to be opened. The mass graves in Kocho and Solagh were the first ones to be exhumed from March 2019, followed by Hardan in February 2022 and Qney in June 2022 . This is believed to be the sixth batch of remains of Yazidi victims to be returned to Sinjar and a total of 41 victims were identified. Previously, remains have been returned mainly to Kocho and Solagh and the identification process is still ongoing. Support provided by Yazda and partners As for previous ceremonies, Yazda and other organizations will accompany Yazidi community members during this extremely sensitive time. Yazda has been coordinating the process over the past months with the national authorities and members of the community as well as partners from the International Organization for Migration (IOM), UNITAD and Nadia’s Initiative which will be present to provide support during the ceremonies. From its side, Yazda will deploy different teams to the burial sites. Yazda’s Case Managers will be present to provide psychological support and Yazda’s Mobile Medical Unit will provide medical assistance to the community where needed. Yazda’s Documentation Team will film the official speeches, report on the ceremonies and interview the authorities and partners, including members of the MLD and representatives of UNITAD and ICMP. The community will be invited to provide feedback on the process and report any concerns. Yazda’s Investigation Coordinator and focal point for the event, Ismail Qasim comments: “We have been supporting the process of exhumations over the past 5 years at least and it is far from being done. The crime scenes left by ISIL are countless and necessite joint efforts from all stakeholders involved, including internationals. Therefore, it is crucial that Iraq continues its collaboration with entities such as UNITAD to support the affected communities to recover the remains and bury them in a dignified way." Yazda presents its condolences to all the affected families as well as the wider Yazidi community and reiterates its commitment to work tirelessly in the pursuit of justice and the truth. For the Arabic version of the Press Release, click here .
© Corporate compliance insights
by Farhad Ali 18 Jan, 2024
Yazda welcomes the decision rendered on the 16 th January, 2024, by the Cour de Cassation, the French Supreme Court, confirming the indictment of Lafarge, now Holcim, for complicity in crimes against humanity. This decision echoes the landmark ruling in this case rendered in September 2021 , which held that any person can be indicted as an accomplice to crimes against humanity, if it knowingly provided support to the perpetrator of such crimes, even in the absence of intent to associate oneself with the commission of their crimes or to adhere to their criminal projects. With this new decision by the Cour de Cassation, the victims of the Syrian and Iraqi conflict are a step closer to justice for the horrors inflicted upon them by ISIS and other terror groups. This decision validates the gravity of the allegations against Lafarge and sends a strong signal that corporations must be held accountable for their actions, especially when they may contribute to crimes against humanity. “Yazda reiterates its commitment to seeking justice for the Yazidi community and other victims of ISIS. As a civil party in the Lafarge case, Yazda will continue to actively participate in the legal proceedings, in the pursuit of truth and accountability,” commented Natia Navrouzov, Legal Advocacy Director at Yazda. “This decision constitutes a significant milestone in these critically important proceedings, which will serve as a landmark for corporate accountability for international crimes. Despite numerous attempts by the defendants to obtain the dismissal of the charges of complicity of crimes against humanity on technicalities, we are now one step closer to having this case heard by a trial court and decided on its merits”, commented Luke Vidal, counsel for Yazda. For the Arabic version of the Press Release, click here . ### 300 North 27th Street, Suite C. - Lincoln, Nebraska 68503, USA info@yazda.org - www.yazda.org
رؤية المزيد
Share by: